| New South Wales State Championship Winners | |||
| Back to champions index | |||
| Association Cup - Rainsford Trophy (the trophy was actually fictional) | |||
| Year | Winners | Score | Losing Finalists |
| 1885 | Granville | 3:1 | Caledonian |
| 1886 | Granville | 3:1 | Canterbury |
| 1887 | Hamilton Athletics | 4:1 | Granville |
| Gardiner Challenge Cup | |||
| Year | Winners | Score | Losing Finalists |
| 1888 | Caledonian | 4:2 | Parkgrove |
| 1889 | Pyrmont Rangers | 2:2 1-0 | Joadga (Southern Cross) |
| 1890 | Pyrmont Rangers | 3:1 | Granville |
| 1891 | Parkgrove | 4:1 | Pyrmont Rangers |
| 1892 | Minmi Rangers | 3-0 | Pyrmont Rangers |
| 1893 | Pyrmont Rangers | 1-0 | Minmi Rangers |
| 1894 | Pyrmont Rangers | 7:2 | Parkgrove |
| 1895 | Balmain | 4:1 | Pyrmont Rangers |
| 1896 | Balmain | 3:1 | Pyrmont Rangers |
| 1897 | Balmain | 2:1 | Pyrmont Rangers |
| 1898 | Volunteers | 3:2 | West Newcastle |
| 1899 | Pyrmont Rangers | 5:2 | Balgownie |
| 1900 | West Wallsend | 3:3 4:1 | Volunteers |
| 1901 | West Wallsend | 4:1 | Balgownie Rangers |
| 1902 | Pyrmont Rovers | 3:1 | West Wallsend |
| 1903 | Pyrmont District | 4:2 | Glebe |
| 1904 | Granville | 2:1 | Glebe |
| 1905 | Balmain | 2:2 2:1 | Rozelle |
| 1906 | Glebe | 3:2 | Pyrmont District |
| 1907 | Broadmeadow | 0:0 3:2 | Pyrmont District |
| 1908 | Pyrmont District | 4-0 | Glebe |
| 1909 | Adamstown Rosebud | 0:0 3:0 | Pyrmont District |
| 1910 | H.M.S. Powerful | 2-0 | Helensburgh |
| 1911 | Balmain | 2:1 | H.M.S. Powerful |
| 1912 | Balmain | 1-0 | Sydney |
| 1913 | Annandale | 3-0 | Newtown |
| 1914 | Granville | 3:0 | Merewether Advance |
| 1915 | Balmain | 2-0 | West Wallsend |
| 1916 | No Competition | ||
| 1917 | No Competition | ||
| 1918 | Weston United | 1-0 | Balmain Kia-Ora |
| 1919 | Balmain Fernleigh | 3-0 | West Wallsend |
| 1920 | Balmain Fernleigh | 2-0 | Granville |
| 1921 | West Wallsend | 3:1 | Granville |
| 1922 | Granville | 1-0 | West Wallsend |
| 1923 | West Wallsend | 0:0 4:4 1-0 | Sydney |
| 1924 | West Wallsend | 3-0 | Woonona |
| 1925 | Adamstown Rosebud | 2-0 | Cessnock |
| 1926 | West Wallsend | 2:1 | Adamstown Rosebud |
| 1927 | Gladesville-Ryde | 2-0 | Granville |
| 1928 | Thirroul | 3-0 | Pyrmont |
| Number of Gardiner Cup wins | |||
| 7 | Balmain | ||
| 6 | West Wallsend | ||
| 5 | Pyrmont Rangers | ||
| 3 | Granville | ||
| 2 | Adamstown Rosebud | ||
| 2 | Balmain Fernleigh | ||
| 2 | Pyrmont District | ||
| 1 | Annandale | ||
| 1 | Broadmeadow | ||
| 1 | Caledonian | ||
| 1 | Gladesville-Ryde | ||
| 1 | Glebe | ||
| 1 | HMS Powerful | ||
| 1 | Minmi Rangers | ||
| 1 | Parkgrove | ||
| 1 | Pyrmont Rovers | ||
| 1 | Thirroul | ||
| 1 | Volunteers | ||
| 1 | Weston United (combind Weston & Hebburn team) | ||
| Back to champions index | |||